Lesson 00
An introductory lesson on the importance and definition of usul al-fiqh, Imam al-Shafi'i's authorship of al-Risala and his distinctive qualities, and the meaning of manuscript verification as applied by Shaykh Ahmad Shakir to the book.
Article Series
Summary of the Explanation of al-Risala by Shaykh Dr. Ahmad al-Naqeeb
A lesson-by-lesson summary of Shaykh Dr. Ahmad al-Naqeeb's explanation of al-Risala by Imam al-Shafi'i, prepared from the audio recordings of the lessons. It opens with an introductory lesson on the definition and origins of usul al-fiqh and the place of al-Risala in it, then follows the text from its preface through the chapters on clarification and the place of the Sunnah relative to the Qur'an to the legal examples al-Shafi'i uses. The summary keeps the definitions, examples and distinctions the teacher points out, such as the difference between what "disliked" (karaha) meant for al-Shafi'i and for later jurists.
Fiqh and Legal Theory 74 parts First: 2024-12-28 Latest: 2024-12-28
Series parts
Read in order
Lesson 01
The first session on al-Risala covers al-Shafi'i's opening praise, the two kinds of disbelievers before the Prophet's mission, the raising of the Prophet's mention, and the virtue of sending blessings upon him ﷺ.
Lesson 02
This session explains several expressions in al-Shafi'i's introduction, distinguishes text from inference, argues that revelation guides every new event, and introduces al-Shafi'i's concept of bayan and its three kinds in the Book of Allah.
Lesson 03
This session defines ijtihad, applies it to facing the qiblah, restricts speaking about religion to reasoning from evidence, and explains the first two kinds of bayan through the examples of tamattu' in Hajj and the verse of ablution.
Lesson 04
This session continues the first two kinds of bayan with the verses of fasting and ablution, then turns to inheritance and voluntary bequests, the fixed times of prayer, and the unqualified command as an indicator of obligation.
Lesson 05
This session explains the two ways of analogy and the notion of the effective cause, the Arabic language of the Qur'an and the kinds of words used by the Arabs, the issue of surrogacy, and further rulings on prayer times and unqualified commands.
Lesson 06
This session covers consensus and disagreement, the Arabic tongue of the Qur'an, abrogation and its broader usage among legal theorists, the role of the Prophet ﷺ in clarifying revelation, the manners of one devoted to the Book and the Sunnah, and the duty to speak only from knowledge.
Lesson 07
This session refutes the claim that the Qur'an contains non-Arabic words, distinguishes blameworthy from acceptable imitation, explains the ranks of scholars and how no one encompasses the whole of the language or the Sunnah, and defines who belongs to the people of the Arabic tongue.
Lesson 08
This session discusses the scholarly views on the origin of language, how non-Arabic tongues may coincide with Arabic, the proof that the Book of Allah is in the Arabic tongue, and the amount of Arabic every Muslim must learn.
Lesson 09
This session explains the role of reading aloud in learning a language and the distinctive features of the Arabic tongue, including its breadth, its general and specific expressions, synonyms and polysemy, and the Arabs' reliance on memorization.
Lesson 10
On al-Shafi'i's chapter on general Qur'anic wording that is meant generally yet admits specification, covering wholly general verses, generality limited by sense and context, the functions of the definite article, and the importance of the occasion of a hadith.
Lesson 11
On al-Shafi'i's chapter on Qur'anic wording that is general in appearance yet combines generality and specification, illustrated through verses on piety, fasting, prayer, and the word "people," with notes on attributing chapter headings to an author and on clear communication.
Lesson 12
On al-Shafi'i's chapter on the category whose meaning is clarified by its context, explaining what context means and showing through the verses on the town by the sea and the destroyed cities that "town" refers to its inhabitants, with a note on the speaker's duty to be clear.
Lesson 13
On al-Shafi'i's chapter establishing that the Sunnah may specify the general wording of the Qur'an, illustrated through the rulings of inheritance, ablution, theft, and fornication.
Lesson 14
Continuing the discussion of how the Sunnah specifies the general wording of the Qur'an, with further detail on wiping over leather socks, the conditions for amputation in theft, the punishment for fornication, and the share of the near relatives in the spoils of war.
Lesson 15
On al-Shafi'i's chapter on Allah's obligation in His Book to follow the Sunnah of His Prophet ﷺ, covering the Prophet's station in the religion, the Book and the Wisdom, and the relationship between obeying Allah and His Messenger and obeying those in authority.
Lesson 16
On al-Shafi'i's chapter on Allah's command to obey His Messenger ﷺ, discussing the verses that make obedience to him obedience to Allah, the status of his independent reasoning, and the obligation to submit to his judgment.
Lesson 17
On al-Shafi'i's chapter on Allah's obligation upon His Messenger to follow what was revealed to him, covering the kinds of revelation addressed to the Prophet ﷺ, his protection from being misled, and responses to those who cast doubt on the Sunnah.
Lesson 18
On paragraph 294 of al-Risala, explaining the obligation to follow the Prophet's ﷺ Sunnah, the ways in which the Sunnah relates to the Qur'an, the views on Sunnah that has no basis in a Qur'anic text, and several methodological benefits.
Lesson 19
An introduction to abrogation (naskh) in al-Risala: its definition and types, why it is a mercy, and Imam al-Shafi'i's position that the Qur'an is abrogated only by the Qur'an and the Sunnah only by the Sunnah.
Lesson 20
This lesson distinguishes informative from performative speech, explains that abrogation applies only to rulings and how it is known, and sets out Imam al-Shafi'i's view that abrogation occurs only by a source of the same kind.
Lesson 21
Imam al-Shafi'i's argument that the Sunnah is abrogated only by Sunnah, his warning against unsupported claims of abrogation, and his account of how the obligation of the night prayer was abrogated.
Lesson 22
This lesson covers the conditions of legal capacity for prayer, how menstruation and intoxication affect it, the purity required for prayer and circumambulation, and the difference between a deed's validity and its reward.
Lesson 23
This lesson treats abrogation shown partly by the Book and partly by the Sunnah, through three cases: the change of the qiblah, the ratio of combatants in battle, and the punishments for unlawful intercourse.
Lesson 24
This lesson treats abrogation indicated by the Sunnah and consensus, centered on how the hadith "No bequest for an heir" abrogated the bequest to inheriting parents and relatives, and completes the discussion of the punishments for unlawful intercourse.
Lesson 25
This lesson opens the chapter on obligations whose text Allah revealed, explaining the terms obligation and explicit text and applying them to the punishment for false accusation and to the mutual imprecation (li'an) between spouses.
Lesson 26
This lesson shows where the Qur'an is clear enough to need no Sunnah, as in li'an and the fast of Ramadan, and where the Sunnah explains ambiguous or summary wording, as in the meaning of marriage after a final divorce and the details of ablution and the ritual bath.
Lesson 27
This lesson explains what an explicitly stated obligation is and how the Sunnah clarifies it through conditions and impediments, using the Qur'anic inheritance shares, the conditions and impediments of inheritance, and the rulings of sale.
Lesson 28
Continuing the chapter on the summaries of obligations, this lesson shows how the Qur'an establishes prayer, zakah, and Hajj while the Sunnah explains how they are performed, including voluntary prayer while riding, the Eid, rain, and eclipse prayers, and delaying prayer for an excuse.
Lesson 29
This lesson treats the fear prayer, from the combining of prayers on the day of the Trench before its revelation to the form prayed at Dhat al-Riqa' and practical questions about applying it in modern armies, along with a note on how al-Shafi'i names narrators across his books.
Lesson 30
This lesson covers the chapter on Hajj and the Book's need for the Sunnah, the obligation to follow authentic Sunnah over any scholar's contrary opinion, the types of waiting periods ('iddah), and the women one is forbidden to marry.
Lesson 31
This lesson explains the conditional permissibility in the verse on marriage, the ruling on a fifth wife, and the chapter on forbidden foods, where the Sunnah adds prohibitions beyond those named in the verse, before closing with marriage to women of the People of the Book and the difference between a ruling and a fatwa.
Lesson 32
This lesson affirms the Sunnah's standing alongside the Book and applies it to the waiting period after a husband's death, what the mourning woman must avoid, where she stays, indirect divorce, and the oath of declaring one's wife forbidden.
Lesson 33
This lesson opens al-Shafi'i's chapter on the underlying meanings ('ilal) in hadiths, covering the categories of hadiths, his use of the term nass, the elements of analogy, reconciling apparently conflicting hadiths, general and specific wording in the Prophet's speech, abrogation, and the value of al-Risala being in al-Shafi'i's own hand.
Lesson 34
This lesson continues the relationship between the Sunnah and the Book, defining the Sunnah, distinguishing customary from legislative acts of the Prophet ﷺ, and showing how apparently conflicting hadiths are reconciled before resorting to abrogation.
Lesson 35
This lesson continues the topic of abrogation, presenting its meanings among the legal theorists, al-Shafi'i's view that the Qur'an is not abrogated by the Sunnah, the prohibition of opposing an authentic hadith, the change of the qiblah as a model case, and the priority of reconciling texts over declaring them abrogated.
Lesson 36
This lesson continues the relationship between the Sunnah and the Qur'an, showing how the Sunnah explains the Qur'an's general rulings on prayer, zakah, Hajj, theft, and fornication, and refuting both the fabricated hadith about testing the Sunnah against the Qur'an and the call to discard the Sunnah.
Lesson 37
Through al-Shafi'i's examples of Qur'anic texts that are general in wording but specified by the Sunnah, this lesson covers combining a woman with her aunt in marriage, wiping over leather socks, fanged beasts of prey, and prohibited sales, along with his view of the solitary report and of the term karahah.
Lesson 38
Concludes al-Shafi'i's discussion of abrogation between the Sunnah and the Qur'an, using the delayed prayer at al-Khandaq and the fear prayer at Dhat al-Riqa' as the test case. It also distinguishes the school of al-Shafi'i from that of the later Shafi'is.
Lesson 39
Explains the concept of variety-based difference (ikhtilaf al-tanawwu') through the 'Asr prayer at Banu Qurayzah and the various wordings of the tashahhud. It presents al-Shafi'i's principle that differences in wording are acceptable so long as the meaning is not altered.
Lesson 40
Treats the kind of difference that calls for reconciliation and preference between texts, taking the hadiths on riba al-fadl and the hadith of Usamah "Riba is only in deferment" as the main example. It shows how al-Shafi'i reconciles them and prefers the more numerous and better-established reports.
Lesson 41
Stresses that a student of knowledge must distinguish points of consensus from points of disagreement, then works through examples of reconciling texts: facing the qiblah when relieving oneself, ruqyah, and drinking while standing. It closes with the rules of imitation and inference and a response to al-Shawkani on conflicts between the Prophet's words and actions.
Lesson 42
Reconciles the hadith of al-Sa'b ibn Jaththamah ("They are of them") with the prohibition on killing women and children, explaining what the phrase means and when non-combatants may be harmed. It also sets out the Qur'anic rulings on accidental killing, including expiation and the blood money borne by the 'aqilah.
Lesson 43
Opens the chapter on the solitary report (khabar al-wahid) with al-Shafi'i's conditions for accepting it, including integrity, precision, verbatim transmission, freedom from tadlis, and a connected chain. It then compares the solitary report with legal testimony, showing where the two agree and where they differ.
Lesson 44
Continues al-Shafi'i's debate on the solitary report, showing that it is a foundation in itself and that, like testimony, it is established by both report and inference despite differing in some details. It also covers women's testimony in matters particular to women and the role of recognized custom.
Lesson 45
A detailed summary of al-Shafi'i's continued debate on the solitary report, showing that it is an independent foundation and that its comparison with testimony does not hold in every respect. It also covers women's testimony in matters particular to women, recognized custom, and a response to calls for absolute equality between men and women.
Lesson 46
Explains al-Shafi'i's second category of knowledge, the derived obligations known through solitary reports, interpretation, and analogy, which are communal obligations (fard kifayah). Jihad is the main example, alongside the Ummah's shared responsibility for these obligations and the danger of neglecting them.
Lesson 47
Praises Imam al-Shafi'i's manners and method of writing and classifies today's students of knowledge into three types. It then begins al-Shafi'i's proof for the solitary report, explaining the hadiths "May Allah brighten the face of a man who hears my words" and "Three things over which a Muslim's heart does not harbour rancour".
Lesson 48
Continues al-Shafi'i's proof for the solitary report through the hadiths "May Allah brighten the face..." and "Let me not find one of you reclining on his couch", with a response to those who set the people of hadith against the jurists. It closes with the change of the qiblah at Quba' as decisive evidence that the Companions acted on a single reporter's news.
Lesson 49
Opens with the speaker's commentary on the current campaign against the Salafi trend, then returns to al-Shafi'i's proofs for the solitary report. These include the prohibition of wine, the days of Tashriq, the standing at 'Arafah, and the mission of Abu Bakr and 'Ali to the Hajj.
Lesson 50
The lesson opens with the standing of scholars in the Ummah, then continues Imam al-Shafi'i's case for the authority of the solitary report, drawing on the Prophet's practice of sending single agents, envoys, and expedition commanders.
Lesson 51
Imam al-Shafi'i continues proving the authority of the solitary report through the Companions' rulings, above all 'Umar's judgment on the blood-money for fingers and his return to the letter of 'Amr ibn Hazm, with examples of imams abandoning their own views for a Prophetic report.
Lesson 52
Imam al-Shafi'i shows how the authority of the solitary report shaped the Companions' views, citing 'Umar's retractions on a wife's share of blood-money, the blood-money for the fetus, and jizyah from the Magians, and explains that the proof lies in a Companion's narration rather than his practice.
Lesson 53
Imam al-Shafi'i explains that 'Umar's request for a second witness to Abu Musa's report was a matter of caution rather than a rejection of the solitary report, sets out the possible reasons for such a request, and argues from the Qur'an that proof is established by a single messenger.
Lesson 54
Imam al-Shafi'i establishes that a solitary report is accepted even when the narrator is a woman, distinguishing narration from testimony and citing the hadith of al-Furay'ah bint Malik and Ibn 'Abbas's ruling on the menstruating pilgrim and the farewell tawaf.
Lesson 55
Imam al-Shafi'i further proves the authority of the trustworthy solitary report through the Companions' conduct, including Ibn 'Abbas relying on Ubayy ibn Ka'b's report about Musa and al-Khidr and Ibn 'Umar abandoning *mukhabarah* on the report of Rafi' ibn Khadij.
Lesson 56
Imam al-Shafi'i gives further examples of the Companions and their successors accepting and acting on the solitary report, including Abu al-Darda' censuring Mu'awiyah over the sale of gold and silver and 'Umar ibn 'Abd al-'Aziz reversing his ruling on the hadith that profit follows liability.
Lesson 57
Imam al-Shafi'i affirms that the jurists never differed over establishing the solitary report in principle, and sets out the only grounds on which a scholar may set aside an authentic report, an argument later echoed by Ibn Taymiyyah in excusing the imams.
Lesson 58
Imam al-Shafi'i grounds the authority of the solitary report in the practice of the Salaf across the major cities, lists the only valid grounds for a scholar to depart from an authentic hadith, and offers an excuse for the imams in their apparent contradictions of texts.
Lesson 59
Imam al-Shafi'i continues affirming the authority of the solitary report and its transmission by the Successors, and the commentator explains the grounds on which a scholar is excused for departing from a hadith, the basis of Ibn Taymiyyah's *Raf' al-Malam*.
Lesson 60
Imam al-Shafi'i details the kinds of proof, distinguishing decisive texts from the solitary report, then turns to the disconnected and *mursal* hadith and sets out the ways in which a *mursal* report can be strengthened so that he accepts it.
Lesson 61
After an introduction to *al-Risalah* and its importance, this lesson covers al-Shafi'i's debate on the authority of the *mursal* hadith and his conditions for accepting it, and discusses whether a Companion's statement is a proof in his school.
Lesson 62
Imam al-Shafi'i's censure of those who settle for little knowledge, accept weak reports, and neglect distinguishing sound narrations from weak ones, with notes on why experts are wary of the mursal reports of those below the senior Successors.
Lesson 64
The opening of Imam al-Shafi'i's chapter on consensus (ijma'): its meaning, its authority, its textual basis, and the principle that the Ummah does not agree on contradicting the Sunnah, with notes on combining apparently conflicting texts.
Lesson 65
Imam al-Shafi'i's chapter on analogy (qiyas): its definition, pillars, and relation to ijtihad, the principle that every occurrence has a ruling, and the kinds of knowledge, including judging by the apparent while the hidden belongs to Allah.
Lesson 66
Imam al-Shafi'i's chapter on ijtihad: its meaning, its relation to analogy, and his argument from facing the qiblah that two mujtahids may reach different conclusions while each fulfils what is required of him.
Lesson 67
Imam al-Shafi'i continues the chapter on ijtihad with two examples: estimating the equivalent compensation for game killed in ihram, and assessing the probity of witnesses.
Lesson 68
A quick review of analogy (its pillars, valid and invalid forms, and istihsan), followed by paragraph 1467 onward on the conditions and etiquette of the mujtahid and the difference between the error of a scholar and that of an ignorant person.
Lesson 69
Continuing the conditions and etiquette of the mujtahid from paragraph 1474: fair-mindedness, knowing one's basis, the conclusive proof, analogy as a recourse of necessity, and the difference between taqlid and ittiba'.
Lesson 70
From paragraph 1480, practical examples and types of analogy with a focus on a fortiori analogy (qiyas al-awla), along with discussion of suspicion, good opinion of Muslims, and the difference between taqlid and ittiba'.
Lesson 71
From paragraph 1494, al-Shafi'i's conditions for analogy and the concept of resemblance between original and branch, illustrated through the rulings on maintenance: the father's duty to support his child and nursing mother, and the child's duty to support a needy parent.
Lesson 72
An overview of the proofs of legal rulings, consensus and its kinds, detailed evidence, ijtihad, and the pillars of analogy, with digressions on the term nass, the categories of the Shi'ah, and why dividing issues into usul and furu' by the presence of dispute is imprecise.
Lesson 73
An introduction to *al-Risalah* and its lost early commentaries, followed by analogy in the ribawi commodities: the scholars' views on the effective cause of riba, the Zahiri position, the conditions for exchanging like commodities, and al-Shafi'i's extension of the ruling to weighed foods and drinks.
Lesson 74
Clarifications on measured-by-volume and weighed commodities, genus versus type in the rules of riba, the zakah of gold, silver, and crops, and then the rulings on blood money (diyah), the categories of killing, and the 'aqilah.