Al-Bukhari and the Umayyad and Abbasid State: A Study of the Claim of Politicization

Details

Al-Bukhari and the Umayyad and Abbasid State

A Study of the Claim of Politicization

This article challenges the modern allegation that Imam al-Bukhari’s Sahih was shaped by political pressures from the Umayyad or Abbasid states. It argues that this claim is historically weak, methodologically unsound, and largely driven by ideological agendas among Orientalist, modernist, and sectarian critics.

The article explains that such accusations often trace back to the writings of Goldziher and later Arab modernists, who claimed that al-Bukhari’s choices of narrations and transmitters were influenced by political concerns, especially in matters related to the virtues of certain Companions. The article presents this as part of a broader effort to undermine Sunni hadith authority rather than a conclusion grounded in careful historical reading.

It then points to the actual political context of al-Bukhari’s life. He lived during periods in which Abbasid rulers themselves adopted theological positions opposed to the creed of the hadith scholars, especially during the era of the Mihnah. Rather than appearing as a court-dependent compiler, al-Bukhari emerges as someone whose doctrinal commitments often stood in tension with ruling power. His chapter headings in matters of creed are themselves presented as evidence of intellectual independence.

The article also draws on biographical reports showing that al-Bukhari kept his distance from rulers and refused to demean sacred knowledge by taking it to the doors of the elite. His rejection of special treatment from governors and his later expulsion from Bukhara are offered as further evidence that he was not a political instrument.

Its conclusion is that the claim of politicization collapses before the combined weight of biography, context, and method. Al-Bukhari’s criteria in narration were scholarly rather than political, and his Sahih remains a work of independent hadith criticism rather than a product of state engineering.

Original publication

This article is also published on Alukah Network

This page presents an organized in-site version of the article within the website archive, while the original publication remains available on Alukah Network.

Go to the article on Alukah Network